This Page

has moved to a new address:


Sorry for the inconvenience…

Redirection provided by Blogger to WordPress Migration Service
A Reader of Fictions: Cry Baby Cry - The Beatles

A Reader of Fictions

Book Reviews for Just About Every Kind of Book

Friday, August 6, 2010

Cry Baby Cry - The Beatles

Birthmarked, Book 1

Caragh M. O'Brien
young adult, dystopia

Brief Summary:

Birthmarked is one of many in the recent wave of dystopias. This future America has clearly had some sort of environmental cataclysm; the lakes (called unlakes) are dry and rain comes but infrequently. Crops are difficult to sustain, so mycoprotein, which can be grown without sunlight, has become important for subsistence. The society consists of the better-off people inside the Wall, who have technology and running water. Outside the wall, they live more like subsistence farmers or a third world country.

Sixteen year old Gaia has lived a pleasant, if hard-working, life outside the Wall. Her mother works as a midwife and Gaia is finally old enough to be making it her career as well, no longer merely an apprentice to her mother. Her life is not an easy one, but she is happy and dearly loves her mother and father. The only thing that mars her existence is the scar on her face, which prevented her from being Advanced (taken to be adopted by a family inside the city). Midwives have to Advance a quote of a babies every month and the mothers just have to accept this; Gaia's mother gave her first two children, both sons, to be Advanced.

Gaia's life is thrown into chaos when she discovers that her parents have been arrested. She cannot fathom why this has happened and doesn't know what to do. All she has is a small mysterious package, the last thing given to her by her parents, and a guard interrogating her in her parent's house. Disgruntled with life after these new revelations, Gaia determines to sneak into the city to find, and possibly rescue her parents. She finds that life is not necessarily any better behind the Wall and that first impressions can be quite wrong, even about herself.

Birthmarked is a good read, not incredibly fast paced, the way The Hunger Games is, but it moves along steadily. The characters feel realistic and multidimensional. My only real criticism of the novel is that I could not picture any of the characters. O'Brien does wonderful descriptions of the places and the codes, but does not tend to describe people, except some of the details. This may be a good thing, if you are one of the people who likes being able to create the character's physical appearance in your mind. (Personally, I like to have a 'correct' picture, by which I mean based on the canon of the author's description.)

I do not want to spoil anything, because I know that is unbearably obnoxious, but I will say that this book flows much more like a traditional dystopia and less like some of the more cheerful ones coming out for children now. Some comparisons could be made here perhaps to The Handmaid's Tale, although obviously less harsh for the teen audience. O'Brien came up with a different plot line, focusing less on how the society came about and more on the problems within it (particularly the unforeseen complications a small population can bring). I highly recommend this as one of the better written and more original books coming out now.

Labels: , , ,


Post a Comment

Every comment is appreciated and I will almost always respond, because I love conversing about books!

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home